Alternative to the iPhone, iTouch, WM6x for Portable Computing

Posted by JD 07/27/2008 at 20:52

For the last few years, we’ve all seen the iPhone, iTouch, WindowsMobile, and Blackberry options for portable computing. Each has there place, especially when you aren’t paying for them.

I have a few problems with them – the radio and that they aren’t general purpose computers with lots and lots of free software. Basically, I wanted a platform that could do the following things in a highly portable container, securely, with great battery life.

  1. IMAPS email to my server
  2. Browse the real web, not some mobile-limited sites only
  3. wifi with WPA2 as the default network
  4. Skype and SIP clients for voice calls (I use my cell phone tho)
  5. MP3 playback (other formats supported too) OGG or other codecs you decide, not Apple
  6. Occasional video playback – mp4 and many, many other formats via mplayer
  7. rsync/ssh to servers
  8. Mapping/GPS (with a tiny GPS Receiver added on)
  9. Blogging and note taking device (with an iGo Bluetooth keyboard)
  10. Nearly unlimited expansion via memory (SD cards)
  11. disconnected from the cell network, so the connectivity can be upgraded outside this device. I use a cheap Motorola cell phone with a 3G data plan via Bluetooth when there’s no wifi available.
  12. USB connectivity to pull photos from a camera during travels (yes, swapping memory would be better, but I sadly bought a Sony camera). External HD also support this way.
  13. Youtube to kill some time. Other video formats are supported, but some are challenging for playback – it is only a 400MHz CPU after all. That doesn’t mean you can’t convert with a simple script into whatever format works best.
  14. High res screen (800×480)

So there’s a bunch of bluetooth happening here. Why? Bluetooth connection mean the cell phone radio can be upgraded as desired – -fairly cheaply. It also stays in the backpack – same for the GPS receiver, and keyboard if you plan to type much.

My solution? Why, a Nokia N800. It runs Linux, so there are many, many free applications. It is backed by Nokia, so there’s a commercial GPS app. I use Maemo Mapper – completely free. Since it runs Linux, when I’m at home, I can ssh into the device and setup files, move music or other files over, and pull photos off it. The uses are nearly unlimited and completely under your control.

The best part? In Feb 2008, an N800 costs $219. That’s half the price of an iPhone – with no monthly data plan payment needed. AND I can load the apps I like, not just apps that Apple or Nokia think I should. Pick an audio file format, you can probabaly use it, provided the DRM works. If it doesn’t, convert it to any format you like – FLAC, OGG, MP3, MP4, whatever you need. Same for video.

The Nokia isn’t perfect. Typing without an external keyboard sucks. It is a read-only device then. That means replying to email isn’t something you’ll do very much. If that’s what you need – get a Blackberry. But when you are portable and on the move, read-only is generally what you need. Reading PDF docs, recording voice notes, using Skype for international calls, using the GPS to find a shortcut or simply listening to your favorite music for a few hours on an airplane. The N800 does all these things nicely, without the extra cost of the other alternatives or the weight of a full laptop. Even taking a keyboard, GPS receiver, and tiny router, we’re still way under the size and weight of most laptops.

Sometimes you just want a small cell phone and don’t want to carry more. How’s that iPhone then? Some more reasons
and a demo of an N770 you may like. That is an older model.

Comparison between the N800 and iTouch might be better? They cost about the same amount. Here’s the big differences, as I see them:

  1. swap the memory or not?
  2. General purpose browser (Mozilla) or specialized?
  3. OSS Apps or Apple-only approved apps?
  4. clunky UI or beautifully designed UI? – this could be important to some
  5. Multitude of audio file formats supported like FLAC, OGG, MP3, whatever or just iTunes?
  6. Multitude of video file formats supported (mp4, avi, mpg2, whatever or just iTunes?
  7. IMAPS email or not?
  8. GPS or not?
  9. Skype or not?
  10. Lots of peripherals or lots of expensive peripherals?
  11. General purpose portable computer or specific Music player?

It’s your choice. How much is usability on a limited device worth?

Trackbacks

Use the following link to trackback from your own site:
https://blog.jdpfu.com/trackbacks?article_id=230